Can't make this simple straight route

[EN] I think I have found an issue with the route calculated by Kurviger
[DE] Ich glaube ich habe einen Fehler bei der Routenberechnung von Kurviger gefunden

[EN] I read the corresponding documentation
I’ve checked Openstreets and can’t seem to find any problems with the road.
[DE] Ich habe die entsprechende Documentation dazu gelesen

[EN] Here is a url to a short example (<10km) that shows the issue:

[DE] Hier ist ein Link zu einer kurzen Route (<10km) die das Problem zeigt:

[EN] Description of the issue and how it should work instead:
Should stay on 25/70 from beginning to end
[DE] Beschreibung des Problems und wie es anstatt dessen funktionieren sollte:

1 Like

There had been a wrong turn restriction on OSM.
(forbidden straight on)
I’ve (hopefully) corrected that. I guess “forbidden to turn” should be the right turn restriction here.

In 1-2 weeks Kurviger should work

1 Like

Can you give me more exact details on what section of openstreests this option is correct so I can be on the look out of it in the future?
Any other exact details would help.

1 Like

Was it this section and the “Only Straight On”

An dem Knoten kann es nicht liegen?

It can’t be due to the node

Yes, exactly there.

Before my change it looked like that.

With ID-editor (in the browser) turn restriction are fairly easy changeable:

  • click on the node where the turn restriction aplies.
  • a picture of the intersection apears on the left side.
  • then (on the left side) click on the road where you are comig from.
  • then you can click on the arrows to change.

Mit dem ID-Editor (im Browser) sind die Abbiegebeschränkungen relativ einfach änderbar:

  • Klicke auf den Knoten, für den die Abbiegebeschränkung gilt.
  • es erscheint ein Bild der Kreuzung auf der linken Seite.
  • Dann klicke auf die Straße, von der du kommst (auf der linken Seite).
  • Zum ändern kannst Du dann auf die Pfeile klicken.

Thanks for the change @linux-user. I wonder of the only straight on restriction is even necessary here?

Shouldn’t a no u-turn restriction from the right to the left be enough?

Hmm, you are right.
The “straight on restriction” is superfluous because the “US 25;US 70” is tagged as one-way here.
I think it should look like this:
Coming from the south

Coming from the north
@jfauerba would you like to change it?

I would change it in openstreets if you tell me how?

See my post above:

  • click on the node where the turn restriction applies:
  • select “edit”
  • a picture of the “road splitting” appears on the left side.
  • then (on the left side) click on the road where you are coming from. (here the north part)
  • then you can click on the arrows to change.

At the end it should look like this:

Then you can upload it to OSM.

1 Like

I think I just fixed it.
Not sure if a U-turn is allow here or not.

You have managed it :+1:
I can’t say from the distance (I live in Germany, Europe) if your change is correct (i.e. does it reflect the situation on site).

Now we have

Coming from north:

  • straight on allowed
  • u-turn allowed

Coming from south:

  • straight on allowed
  • u-turn forbidden (i.e. going to the other lane southward)

Hope this helps