Perhaps we may here gather some ideas for enhancements for the “Navigation - Next turn instruction” menu?
Currently chosen option for curvyness + lenght of total route + time of total route
Sometimes while following navigation I get uncertain, wether I really had chosen before the right curvyness option. A tap on the “Next turn menu” could show (and so confirm) it?
Perhaps together with “length + time of total route”, as it is shown for example after creating a route?
Just a note that better be careful with this menu UI, since being used while navigating, so should be compact while its functions easily accessible.
I absolutely agree with that: this dialog should be kept simple and not be overloaded. Detailed informations / options should be handled by using the regular menus.
We can put such information in dialog title, like happens already with routing actions:
Hmm, I am not 100% convinced.
Think, you have to operate this menu with gloves.
Skip next waypoint causes immediate action, so you don’t want to touch that accidentally.
IMHO the check boxes are to close to the
Skip next waypoint action button.
Skip next waypoint more important than the other actions.
skip next waypoint would be a check box as well, which would be cleared after pressing OK?
What do others think?
Also ich finde es gut wenn “Skip next Waypolnt” so wie es abgebildet ein extra Button ist.
That’s was exactly my initial idea and implementation! A list of equal check boxes where everybody can check whatever wishes. “Skip” is just one of them, cleared each time.
Indeed an option should not be more prominent than others, as everyone has different needs and preferences.
If you mean an extra button below, with ok / cancel, that’s not optimal:
- Dialog buttons should have minimal text, “Skip next waypoint” is very large text.
- In future will have more actions, cannot have buttons for each in dialog buttons.
Another idea is to have navigation actions as a buttons list, like the route actions seen above.
In that case would need to find an elegant way to inform inside the buttons their on / off state.
I understand @diesel6876 in the way, that it is GOOD exactly LIKE IT IS in the last picture!
That’s really a matter of taste.
Then you would have to change the text, dependent on the state of the buttons (don’t know if this is possible)
I personally prefer the check-box version.
- disadvantage: One more click
- advantage: No unintentional action that you can’t revert.
@linux-user’s idea (and mine initial) with check boxes would be:
Check boxes & current implementation have 1 extra step (press OK).
Implementation via 1 click buttons could be:
(on / off text representation can be also something else)
I don’t like the idea to handle “skip next waypoint” with a check box. It should be a button like shown in devemux86’s example.
That would be a good alternative!
This menu is meant more for navigation tasks, to be done efficiently while navigation continues.
What is the purpose for clear route (i.e. stop navigation) and not use the current available ways?
It is marginally quicker for one and would also be consistent with the interface in Locus Map Pro which is the other navigation app I use. I do appreciate that this is not necessarily a factor in your thinking however!